Retrospective property valuations: how a property is valued at a past date

A retrospective valuation sets what a property was worth on a date in the past. Here is the process step by step, the evidence a valuer relies on, and what goes in the report.

By Tom Nagy, CPV17 November 20268 min read

The short answer

A retrospective property valuation is a formal valuation of what a property was worth on a specific date in the past, called the valuation date. It is sometimes also called a backdated, historical or retroactive valuation.

Two principles sit at the heart of it:

  • The value rests on sales from before the valuation date. The valuer has to see the market the way a buyer and seller saw it on that day, without the benefit of hindsight.
  • The property is valued as it was on that date. The valuer uses historical photos, including photos published online in old sale and rental listings, to see the condition of the house and other improvements at the time.

The aim is to establish what a willing buyer would reasonably have paid a willing seller on that date.

When you might need one

Retrospective valuations often come up for:

  • capital gains tax, for example when a former home was first rented out, or when a property was inherited. See capital gains tax valuations.
  • deceased estates, where a value at the date of death is needed. See probate and deceased estate valuations.
  • family law, where a value at a past date is sometimes requested alongside a current one. See family law valuations.
  • stamp duty and related-party transfers, where a transfer happened earlier and the value at that time has to be supported. See stamp duty valuations.
  • SMSF reporting for a past financial year, and disputes about past transactions.

Whether you need a valuation, and at which date, is a question for your accountant, lawyer or the relevant authority.

The retrospective valuation process

Step 1: Establish the valuation date

You tell the valuer the historical date the property needs to be valued at. For example:

  • a set date, such as 1 July 2015
  • the date of death of an owner
  • the date a property was transferred
  • the date of purchase or acquisition

The valuation must reflect the property's market value on that particular date. A valuation at the wrong date may be of no use, so confirm the date with your accountant or lawyer, in writing if you can, before you book.

Step 2: Inspect the property

The valuer will generally inspect the property to establish:

  • land size and dimensions
  • building size and construction
  • number of bedrooms and bathrooms
  • condition
  • improvements and renovations
  • overall characteristics

Importantly, the valuer must tell apart the property's condition on the valuation date and its condition today. A kitchen added two years later is ignored. An extension that has since been knocked down is included.

To see what the property was like back then, the current inspection is supplemented by:

  • historical photos, including old sale and rental listings published online
  • your own photos from around that time
  • building permits, plans and council records
  • earlier valuations, appraisals or rate notices
  • the contract of sale from when it was bought

Online listing photos are often the best record of past condition, because they show the inside of the house and are dated by the listing.

Step 3: Research historical comparable sales

This is one of the most important parts of the process. The valuer researches properties that sold around the valuation date and compares them on:

  • location and street appeal
  • land size
  • building size
  • age and condition
  • accommodation
  • quality of improvements
  • sale prices and market conditions at the time

The value rests on sales that happened before the valuation date. Sales shortly after the date may also be considered, but only where they reflect the market as it was on the day. Anything that reflects later changes in the market is set aside. This is the "no hindsight" principle.

Step 4: Analyse historical market conditions

The valuer examines the property market as it was at the valuation date. This may include:

  • historical median house prices
  • local market trends
  • interest rates
  • supply and demand
  • comparable sales evidence
  • economic conditions

Planning and zoning are also taken as they were on the date, not as they are now. Today's market is not relevant.

Step 5: Prepare the valuation report

A formal retrospective valuation report generally includes:

  1. property identification and title details
  2. instructions and purpose of the valuation
  3. the historical valuation date
  4. property description
  5. land and building details
  6. planning and zoning information
  7. historical comparable sales
  8. market analysis
  9. valuation methodology
  10. the assessed market value
  11. the valuer's qualifications and declaration

Where something about the property at the time cannot be confirmed, the report states the assumption made. This lets anyone relying on the report, such as the ATO or a court, see exactly how the value was reached.

What if the property has been renovated or sold since?

That is common and is not a problem. The valuer works out what the property was like at the time from the records above. Details of what was renovated and when help separate the old property from the new one. If it has since sold, the later sale price is not used to set the earlier value.

How far back can a valuation go?

There is no fixed limit. Older dates take more work, because there are fewer recorded sales and fewer photos. The valuer may need to widen the search area or rely more on market trends at the time. Tom has worked in Melbourne real estate since the 1980s, so he has seen many market cycles first-hand.

What you can send to help

  • the exact valuation date and the reason for the valuation
  • the address and, if known, the date the property was bought and the price
  • any photos from around the valuation date
  • dates and details of renovations, extensions or demolitions
  • any earlier valuations, appraisals or council rate notices

The more the valuer knows about the property as it was, the stronger the report.

Will it be accepted?

Bodies like the ATO expect valuations to be done by a suitably qualified, independent valuer, with the evidence and reasoning set out clearly. Tom Nagy is a Certified Practising Valuer (CPV) with current registration with the Australian Property Institute. His reports are accepted by the ATO, the State Revenue Office and the courts.

What it costs

Residential retrospective valuations start from $500. Commercial and industrial property is valued with a long-form report from $975. Older dates or complex properties may take more work, so ask for a quote. See pricing for more.

For capital gains tax situations in more detail, read retrospective valuations for capital gains tax.

Talk to Tom

Call Tom on 0407 835 388 or send an enquiry with the address, the valuation date and the reason you need it. You will speak directly with the valuer.

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice.

Related valuations

Not sure which valuation you need?

Call Tom before you book. You will get a straight answer on the right report for your situation and what it costs.

Call Tom Get a quote